Hand hygiene and hearing loss. Avoiding the tradeoff

Like most people, I was never a fan of the old-fashioned hand dryers in public bathrooms. Unless you had 10 minutes to stand around, the machines never got your hands dry. I used paper towels whenever they were offered.

In recent years more powerful hand dryers have been popping up and now fewer bathrooms offer paper towels.

 

Of the new dryers, my personal favorite is the Dyson airblade. It’s powerful, quiet and has a clever design.

 

But I’m not so fond of the Excel Xlerator. Sure it’s powerful, but it’s also incredibly noisy. I have sensitive ears, and I’m not embarrassed to admit that when I’m exposed to a loud sound I cover my ears with my hands. But of course if I’m drying my hands I can’t use them to protect from the noise.

The Xlerator is loud enough that I suspect it’s a threat to hearing. At the very least it’s so annoying that I bet some people skip hand washing to avoid using it. My gym has one of these beasts and after being bothered by it for a while I decided to research the noise level.

I found a paper on the subject by Jeffrey Fullerton and Gladys Unger from the acoustical consulting firm Acentech. Sure enough, the Xlerator is a real noisemaker. Apparently the company has also developed a noise reduction nozzle, but I don’t think I’ve ever seen one in operation.

I followed up with the authors, who told me that OSHA does not find the level of noise generated by the Xlerator to be a danger to hearing. It’s not loud enough to cause immediate hearing loss and since it’s used for only about 15 seconds at a time it’s not likely to cause permanent damage.

They did advise me to put my hands a foot or so below the nozzle rather than a couple of inches, because hands in the airstream is a major factor in the noise level. 

So today I gave it a shot. If anyone was watching me they probably wondered why I was stooping down to use the dryer. But it actually worked. By keeping my hands lower the noise level was cut to an acceptable level. It took a little longer to dry my hands, but it wasn’t bad.

By David E. Williams of the Health Business Group 

 

 

6 thoughts on “Hand hygiene and hearing loss. Avoiding the tradeoff

  1. GingerR

    Some of the restrooms at work are equipped with those. In a small tile walled restroom it’s like standing next to a jet engine. Two people can’t have a conversation with it blasting away. I don’t think it’s too much to ask for a trip to the restroom to be peaceful and those blowers are not!

    Reply
  2. Pingback: Cavalcade of Risk #181: The ‘What If’ Edition « Healthcare Economist

  3. Excel Dryer

    XLERATOR® is the original, patented high-speed hand drying system that revolutionized the hand dryer industry by completely drying hands three times faster than conventional hand dryers while using 80% less energy and delivering a 95% cost savings versus paper towels.

    In an effort to continue providing the most innovative hand drying experience, Excel Dryer will be releasing an updated XLERATOR® model featuring a new control assembly. The new control assembly has several improved features including a motor speed control to adjust the speed and sound level of the dryer, multiple voltage options of 110V or 208-277V at no additional charge and the ability to turn the heating element on or off, significantly reducing energy consumption.

    Excel Dryer is excited to announce that demonstration units are currently available for presentations and trial period programs only; the product will be available for purchase in early fall.

    Reply
  4. Bob Jacobson

    I’m glad to read I’m not the only one concerned about the noise created by XLERATOR hand dryers. The description posted “like standing next to a jet engine” describes it perfectly. I’m trying to protect my hearing because both my parents developed poor hearing as they got older, and I want to avoid this if possible. In particular, rest areas in Virginia use these hand dryers and if the weather is warm enough, I’ll just go outside and let me hands air-dry.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s